A triangular, buff-colored patch occurs on the snout, and, unlike other frogs in the genus, there is no eye stripe. The throat and chest are often boldly mottled; and the species has indistinct [[dorsolateral]] skin folds and [[granular]] skin. Males of this species develop [[nuptial pad]]s on their thumb bases during the breeding season. These frogs can be identified by their rough skin, horizontal pupils, fully webbed hind feet, and their habit of jumping into moving water.ref
Tadpoles of this species, though, resemble those of the western toad, [[Bufo boreas]]. R. boylii as tadpoles have fairly flattened tails that lack color at the end and are the tallest in the midsection. The mouths of the tadpoles are made for suction to rocks, with teeth rows used for scraping algae and diatoms, unicellular algae with cells walls that contain [[silica]], off of the rocks to which they are clinging. The mouth of the young R. boylii is also helpful in identifying it from B. boreas because the young foothill yellow-legged frogs develop more defined teeth rows after three weeks, while their counterparts do not.ref